Current Flavors
Taste the nostalgia! Discover our array of ice cream flavors—32 delicious hand-dipped options waiting for you at Faye’s Ice Cream Parlor.
Flavors subject to change based on availability.
Bailey’s Irish Cream GF
Bailey’s Irish Cream Flavored Ice Cream
Birthday Cake
Cake Flavored Ice Cream with a Frosting Swirl, Sprinkles, and Chunks of Cake Pieces
Biscoff Cookie
Decadent Cookie Butter Ice Cream with Chunks of Biscoff Cookies
Black Raspberry GF
Ice Cream Infused with a Delicious Raspberry Purée
Brownie Batter
Luxurious Brownie Batter Ice Cream Loaded with Chunks of Real Brownies
Butter Pecan GF
Buttery Ice Cream with Fresh Roasted Pecans Swirled In
DF Candy Cane GF
Dairy-Free Peppermint Ice Cream Loaded with Mint Pieces
Chocolate GF
Rich, Premium Chocolate Ice Cream Loaded with Indulgence In Every Bite
DF Chocolate GF
Dairy-Free Rich and Creamy Chocolate Flavored Ice Cream
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Vanilla Ice Cream with Chocolate Chips and Chunks of Delicious Cookie Dough
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup GF
Chocolate Ice Cream with Loads of Peanut Butter Cups and a Thick Peanut Butter Swirl
Chocolate Raspberry Truffle GF
Delicious Dark Chocolate Ice Cream with Tasty Black Raspberry Swirls and Raspberry Truffle Cups
Coconut Delite
Coconut Ice Cream Loaded with Chunks of Caramel Delite (Samoa) Cookies and A Thick Fudge Swirl
Cookies ’N Cream
Premium Vanilla Ice Cream with Chunks of Oreo Cookies
Fat Elvis GF
Sweet Banana Ice Cream with a Salty Peanut Butter Swirl and Chocolate Flakes
Graham Central Station
Graham Ice Cream with Graham Cracker Chunks, Chocolate Flakes, and A Thick Graham Cracker Swirl
Grasshopper Brownie
Mint Ice Cream Loaded with Crushed Andes Mints and Real Chunks of Brownies
Holy Cannoli
Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Loads of Cannoli Chunks, Chocolate Chips, and a Rich Fudge Swirl
Java Chip GF
Cold Brew Coffee Ice Cream with Loads of Chocolate Flakes
Maple Bacon GF
Maple Flavored Ice Cream with Real Pieces of Bacon Crumbles
Mint Chocolate Chip GF
Mint Ice Cream with Dark Chocolate Flakes
Monster Cookie
Blue Sweet Cream Ice Cream Loaded with Chunks of Oreos, Chocolate Chip Cookies, and Cookie Dough
Moose Tracks GF
Creamy Vanilla Ice Cream Swirled with Rich Fudge and Peanut Butter Cups
Peanut Butter Blast GF
Creamy Peanut Butter Ice Cream Loaded with Reese’s Pieces and Peanut Butter Cups
Salty Caramel Pretzel
Salted Caramel Ice Cream with Loads of Chocolate Covered Pretzels and A Thick Caramel Swirl
Strawberry GF
Delicious Fresh Strawberry Ice Cream Made with Real Strawberries
DF Strawberry GF
Dairy-Free Fresh Strawberry Ice Cream
Strawberry Cheesecake
Premium Cheesecake Ice Cream Swirled with Fresh Strawberry Sauce and Cheesecake Pieces
Teaberry GF
Premium Teaberry Ice Cream
Thin Mint
Light Mint Flavored Ice Cream Loaded with Girl Scout Thin Mint Cookie Pieces
Ube Brownie
Purple Yam Filipino Flavor Ice Cream Loaded with Real Pieces of Brownies
Vanilla GF
Premium Creamy Vanilla Ice Cream
GF = Gluten-Free
DF = Dairy-Free
NSA = No Sugar Added
Proudly Supporting Local Artisans
Ice Cream
At Faye’s, we offer super premium handcrafted ice cream made by Melissa Pierce of The Sugar Shack. Each batch is thoughtfully created with the finest ingredients, ensuring a rich, creamy, and indulgent experience with every bite. Melissa’s commitment to quality shines through in every flavor, from classic favorites to innovative seasonal creations. Whether you’re craving something sweet, tangy, or decadent, our ice cream delivers an unforgettable treat that’s made with love right here in our community.
We will continue to serve Leiby’s Dairy soft serve ice cream. Located in Tamaqua, PA, Leiby’s has been producing ice cream since 1928. For soft serve lovers, there’s nothing like Leiby’s to cool off on a warm day!
Cookies & Baked Goods
Our cookies and baked goods are made by Melissa Napoli of Well Fed Sweets. Melissa turned a lifelong passion for baking into a PA-based bake shop dedicated to slingin’ darn good cookies. Her cookies and brownies are great on their own or as a part of delicious, customizable ice cream sandwiches! She’s on a mission to bake mind-blowing cookies so you don’t have to.
